Journalists praise the atmosphere, world, and how Retro Studios creates tension and a sense of exploring the unknown. They note the well-thought-out level architecture, good puzzles, and balance between classic elements of the series and new mechanics. The visual component was appreciated for its artistic style, rather than a technical revolution. Combat interaction, game pace, and characteristic "Retro Studios touches" received praise.
Among the downsides are simplifications, occasional loss of pace, and repetitive scenes. The plot is not always impressive, and the structure seems too conservative for some players.
Metroid Prime 4 is not perfect, but it offers an atmospheric and well-thought-out adventure that will appeal to fans of the series and lovers of classic exploration games.