Polygon published an article with an unexpected opinion about Red Dead Redemption 2. Eight years after its release, a journalist called the game "a nightmare," sparking heated debates in the community.
The author acknowledged Rockstar Games' technical prowess, attention to detail, and strong storyline, but stated that the project failed in its main goal — it doesn't provide enjoyment from the gameplay.
The main complaint was excessive realism. According to the journalist, hunting quickly becomes monotonous, searching crates takes too long, and controlling a horse on difficult terrain feels heavy and unresponsive. All of this makes the gameplay irritating.
The article also states that in an era of short attention spans, the slow pace imposed by the developers goes beyond reasonable limits and turns entertainment into a tedious chore.
The publication caused a sharp reaction on forums and social networks. Many users accused Polygon of trying to attract attention with provocative material. Fans of the game stated that it is precisely the unhurried pace and detailed world simulation that make Red Dead Redemption 2 unique.