“AI does not create, it appropriates”: European trade unions declare war on neural networks

Unions from the UK, Ireland, Spain, and Italy propose creating a state regulatory body capable of overseeing the use of neural networks in development studios.

European video game industry unions have spoken out against the uncontrolled adoption of generative AI, releasing a manifesto demanding legal regulation of the technology and protection for workers.

The document was published on the website of the British union IWGB with the participation of Game Workers Unite Ireland, Spain’s CSVI, and the FIOM-CGIL shop stewards’ council in Milan.

The authors believe that generative AI harms the gaming industry, its workers, and the projects they create. In their view, some studios virtually force staff to use neural networks, which risks professional burnout, cognitive decline, and a reduction in entry-level job opportunities.

Generative AI has a serious negative impact on workers, diminishing job availability and the appeal of the profession. The best games are made by humans, and humans work better when they are healthy, invested in their craft, honing their skills, and building real-world experience.

Unions also accuse companies of utilizing AI merely to cut labor costs. At the same time, errors made by neural networks are frequently shifted onto employees. The authors also specifically condemn training models on third-party materials without the consent of rights holders and fair compensation for their labor.

Image source: Techworkersinquiry

Among the proposals is the establishment of a state supervisory body capable of auditing AI use, halting its deployment, and penalizing violators. The unions also demand safeguards for employees who refuse to work with neural networks and a ban on using third-party works for model training without the authors’ consent and compensation.

We are under no obligation to accept the use of generative AI in video game production. It is not an inevitability.