Critics emphasize that this is not just a return of the cult franchise, but a bold step forward. Journalists praise the project for its oppressive atmosphere, well-developed monsters, and psychological depth, comparing it to Silent Hill 2. Inverse notes that this is possibly the best installment in the brand's history.
The main innovation is a new location. The story unfolds in the Japanese town of Ebisugao, where folklore combines with the grim reality of the Showa era. The plot about the girl Hinako is called strong and emotional, and her trials are frighteningly modern.
The non-linearity of the plot and the multitude of endings are particularly highlighted, encouraging repeated playthroughs. Game Rant writes that Silent Hill f combines a tense plot with heavy battles, complex puzzles, and high replayability.
Despite minor technical flaws and a controversial emphasis on the combat part, almost all critics agree: Silent Hill f has become a new benchmark for the genre. DualShockers calls it "the darkest and most visually striking part of the franchise".