"Narrative Doesn't Work That Way": Christopher Nolan Accuses Film Critics of Excessive Pickiness

NewsИсточник: Канал HugoDecrypte на YouTube
16:25

The renowned filmmaker believes that critics confuse understanding narrative mechanisms with their ineffectiveness.

Christopher Nolan criticized a common approach to film analysis, where an easily recognizable narrative device is declared ineffective simply because the viewer understands how it works. The director spoke about this in an interview with the Chinese platform Bilibili:

"This is a fundamental mistake of film criticism: the ability to recognize a mechanism does not negate its effect. Today, people reason like this: 'If I understand why a story affects me in such a way, then it didn't work.' But narrative doesn't work that way. The fact that this mechanism can be recognized does not devalue it. When we, storytellers, create a heroic image in a story, we must take into account the energy that the viewer brings to that story, as well as the interaction between our intention and how the audience perceives it. The very fact that people can recognize this mechanism does not make it less effective. Of course, this may be true for individual elements – along with this, the language of cinema also develops, so when a trope becomes too familiar to the audience, it has to be changed."
Christopher Nolan

However, Nolan's films currently have no serious problems with critical reception. The director's latest film, "Odyssey," received 95% positive reviews from critics and 97% from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes, an "A" CinemaScore based on audience feedback after screenings, and 88 points on Metacritic.

In three weeks, "Odyssey" has already grossed $911.4 million worldwide and is close to reaching the billion-dollar mark.